Tuesday, May 17, 2022
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Climate Change News
  • Home
  • Weather
  • Climate Change
  • Global Warming
  • Discussion
No Result
View All Result
Climate Change News
  • Home
  • Weather
  • Climate Change
  • Global Warming
  • Discussion
No Result
View All Result
Climate Change News
No Result
View All Result
Home Climate Change

The Weather Follies: Is Climate Change To Blame For Germany’s Flooding?

July 20, 2021
in Climate Change
4 min read
The Weather Follies: Is Climate Change To Blame For Germany’s Flooding?
585
SHARES
3.3k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Greta Thunberg has declared the floods in Germany, Belgium, and the Netherlands to be the product of man-made climate change, adding: ‘We’re at the very beginning of a climate and ecological emergency, and extreme weather events will only become more and more frequent.’

Well, that’s sorted out that one, then.

We hardly need Angela Merkel or the Prime Minister of the Netherlands, Mark Rutte, to confirm it for us.

Nor, indeed, do we need to hear from Michael Mann – aka Mr. Hockey Stick – to tell us that the floods are the living embodiment of what climate scientists have been warning us about for decades.

It was climate change wot flooded Germany and that is that – there is no reason for any further debate on the issue; indeed, even to suggest that there is a debate to be had is to mark yourself out as an evil ‘denialist’, intent on blinding yourself to deadly reality, and probably in the pay of on an oil company.

Except there is just one niggling little doubt at the back of my mind – and which perhaps ought to be leaping up and down in the minds of Greta and Chancellor Merkel, too.

Far from predicting more summer rainfall in the German Rhineland, climate models have tended to do the opposite: to predict less.

Had these floods occurred during the winter, it would have been reasonable to claim that they were consistent with climate projections.

Had they occurred in Scandinavia or the Baltic states that, too, could have been claimed to be consistent with climate change projections.

But as you can see from the below map put out by the European Environment Agency, the clear prediction for the Rhineland of southwestern Germany, as well as for Belgium and the southern Netherlands, is that summers will become drier.

Indeed, when Germany did have a dry summer last year that, too, was put down to climate change.

Summer change in predicted rainfall (source: European Environment Agency)

Could Germany end up with summers that are generally drier but which nevertheless have more severe incidents of heavy rainfall?

The two are not necessarily inconsistent – except that if you are going to have two months’ worth of rain in a few days, as happened in some places last week, that doesn’t leave a lot of rain for the rest of the summer.

You might also like

Biden’s Climate And Energy Policies Are Pushing Us Into A Green Dystopia

Mission Accomplished: Price Of Oil Hits Biden’s Official Target

In 24 Hours, Dems Send Flurry Of Mixed Messages On Oil, Gas Production

There is an alternative explanation for last week’s floods: that they are mere weather. Weather, indeed, caused similarly devastating floods in nearby areas in 1954, leaving 10,000 Germans homeless.

We went through a similar process with the 2007 floods in southern England. Initially, and lazily, they were attributed by government ministers to climate change – a very convenient thing to blame because, of course, it distracted attention from the failure to provide and maintain flood defenses, and from a disastrous planning policy that allowed new homes to be built on floodplains.

Yet when the Centre for Ecology and Hydrology looked into the 2007 floods it found it couldn’t attribute them to climate change.

To have such large volumes of rainfall in the summer simply wasn’t consistent with models that predicted southern England, like Germany, will see lower summer precipitation in the future.

To lazily blame the German floods on climate change is a case of predicting one thing and then, when the opposite happens, turn round and say ‘look, I told you so’.

If you want to try to blame last week’s floods on climate change, it is first necessary to argue that the models have been wrong all along – and that actually Germany will suffer greater summer precipitation.

But then that might undermine climate models in general.

Alternatively, you can argue that the floods are a weather event that happened in spite of trends towards drier summers in Germany.

Hysteria, I fear, has moved on a bit since 2008 when the Centre for Ecology and Hydrology delivered its report on the 2007 floods. I suspect that public bodies will be more reluctant now to point out what I have just done – and to risk being labeled ‘denialists’.

Read more at Spectator UK

Related

Trackback from your site.

Credit: Source link

Share234Tweet146
Previous Post

German Officials Left Dams Full For Weeks Even With Heavy Rains Forecast

Next Post

Global satellite data shows clouds will amplify global heating

Related Posts

Biden’s Climate And Energy Policies Are Pushing Us Into A Green Dystopia
Climate Change

Biden’s Climate And Energy Policies Are Pushing Us Into A Green Dystopia

March 28, 2022
Mission Accomplished: Price Of Oil Hits Biden’s Official Target
Climate Change

Mission Accomplished: Price Of Oil Hits Biden’s Official Target

March 27, 2022
In 24 Hours, Dems Send Flurry Of Mixed Messages On Oil, Gas Production
Climate Change

In 24 Hours, Dems Send Flurry Of Mixed Messages On Oil, Gas Production

March 26, 2022
Fake Invisible Catastrophes: Why Global Warming Goons Sell Fake Science
Climate Change

Climate Change Is About Control, Stupid – Not The Environment

March 26, 2022
Load More
Next Post
Global warming helps invasive species flourish – study models likely combined effects on ecosystems

Global satellite data shows clouds will amplify global heating

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

3 × three =

Recommended

January 31, 2022 – Watts Up With That?

January 31, 2022 – Watts Up With That?

February 1, 2022
Renewable energy pace must double to limit global warming, IEA says

Renewable energy pace must double to limit global warming, IEA says

December 1, 2021

Don't miss it

No Content Available
Climate Change News

ClimateChange.Live is an online news portal which aims to share Daily Climate News Updates, Global Warming and Weather News. Feel free to get in touch with us!

Whats New Here

  • Biden’s Climate And Energy Policies Are Pushing Us Into A Green Dystopia
  • Why are my allergies so bad? Climate change may be partly to blame. » Yale Climate Connections
  • Sea ice loss of the Barents-Kara Sea enhances the winter warming over the Tibetan Plateau

© 2019 ClimateChange.Live - All rights reserved!

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Weather
  • Climate Change
  • Global Warming
  • Discussion

© 2019 ClimateChange.Live - All rights reserved!

Feel free to subscribe now!

[email-subscribers-form id=”1″]